The rapid development and integration of generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) into our business lives has sparked a debate on the future of legal documentation. For landlords and small business owners, the possibility of near-instant and cheaper cost lease generation is highly appealing.
However, in the context of a commercial lease, reliance on AI is not advisable. While generative models are good at processing syntax, they fundamentally lack the professional legal judgment, jurisdictional precision and commercial nuance required to safeguard a long-term property asset.
The following are just some of the points to bear in mind in the context of AI:-
Cross-jurisdictional risks in a commercial lease
Laws regulating commercial property are localised and also governed by constantly evolving case law. AI models are trained on vast global datasets, making them prone to cross-contaminating legal concepts from different countries or states. It is not always easy to pick up on this when reviewing the output of an AI-generated document, particularly if it uses terminology with which the user is unfamiliar.
For example, an AI tool might smoothly integrate American concepts into a lease intended for a UK property. In the UK, commercial tenancies are strictly bound by frameworks like the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954. If AI incorrectly structures a clause to exclude statutory security of tenure the resulting provisions may be rendered entirely void. For landlords, this could mean tenants inadvertently being granted permanent occupancy rights.
Drafting issues within your commercial lease
A commercial lease needs to precisely delineate liability and allocate risk based on the physical reality of the property. AI operates on linguistic patterns rather than practical understanding, risking ambiguities in responsibility for various aspects.
Key oversights that can be found in AI-generated drafts include:-
- Ambiguous repair obligations: failing to clearly separate a landlord’s structural responsibilities from a tenant’s internal repairing covenants, which can result in costly dilapidations disputes.
- Flawed financial mechanics: errors in drafting complex rent review provisions, service charge caps, or proportional insurance contributions.
- Break clauses: badly drafted clauses that are unclear and which risk arguments further down the line about the interpretation of pre-conditions for a tenant to effectively break the lease.
Eradicating commercial context
No two commercial transactions are the same. A well-drafted lease is a bespoke reflection of market conditions, sector-specific operational needs (such as specialised fit-out periods or restricted user clauses) as well as compromises negotiated between the parties.
AI cannot interpret human intent, weigh relative bargaining power or anticipate the unique operational risks of a business sector. It relies on generalised templates, resulting in rigid agreements. For businesses and landlords, it can result in a lease that ignores operational realities.
Knowledge of proposed changes in the law
Real Estate property practitioners will be aware of forthcoming and proposed changes in the law and will draft documents to reflect this, to ensure that the lease will work for the duration of the term. An AI model may not be able to effectively distinguish between proposed legislative changes and the current legal framework.
Lack of accountability
Perhaps the most critical danger of AI-driven legal drafting is the absence of a regulatory safety net. AI platforms are not licensed practitioners, they owe no fiduciary duties to users, and carry no professional indemnity insurance.
If a poorly drafted AI clause causes issues there is no recourse. If solicitors are engaged, professional involvement transforms a contract from a liability into a secure asset.
Conclusion: a tool for efficiency, not execution
AI is a transformative tool for preliminary research and administrative streamlining and is fast becoming part of our daily lives. However, its role should be limited to that of an assistant. Entering into a commercial lease which has not been properly drafted can result in significant rectification costs down the line for all parties. While AI can be a useful tool, commercial leases require specialist legal expertise. For advice on drafting or negotiating a commercial lease, please contact Louisa Baker.